Droop quota
| A joint Politics and Economics series |
| Social choice and electoral systems |
|---|
|
|
In the study of electoral systems, the Droop quota (sometimes called the Hagenbach-Bischoff, Britton, or Newland-Britton quota) is the minimum number of votes a party or candidate needs to receive in a district to guarantee they will win at least one seat.
The Droop quota is used to extend the concept of a majority to multiwinner elections, taking the place of the 50% bar in single-winner elections. Just as any candidate with more than half of all votes is guaranteed to be declared the winner in single-seat election, any candidate with more than a Droop quota's worth of votes is guaranteed to win a seat in a multiwinner election.
Besides establishing winners, the Droop quota is used to define the number of excess votes, i.e. votes not needed by a candidate who has been declared elected. In proportional quota–based systems such as STV or expanding approvals, these excess votes can be transferred to other candidates to prevent them from being wasted. (As well, the equivalent of one quota is the number of votes not used to elect someone in many STV contests.)
The Droop quota was first suggested by the English lawyer and mathematician Henry Richmond Droop (1831–1884) as an alternative to the Hare quota and later by Swiss physicist Eduard Hagenbach-Bischof in the context of STV and not for the largest remainder method.
The Droop quota is used in almost all STV elections, including those in Australia, the Republic of Ireland, Northern Ireland, and Malta. It is also used in South Africa to allocate seats by the largest remainder method. Switzerland uses the Droop quota, calling it the Hagenbach-Bischof quota.
Although common, the quota's use in proportional representation has been criticized both for its bias toward large parties and for its ability to create no-show paradoxes, situations where a candidate or party loses a seat as a result of having won too many votes. However, this situation can occur regardless of whether the quota is used with largest remainders or STV. Charges of no-show paradoxes are based on having knowledge of how a vote would be transferred if a candidate were eliminated when that candidate may not have been in real life. It is clear that any system that uses ranked votes produces different results if candidates are in different order, which is partly determined by how votes are split and therefore that charge can apply to any ranked voting system no matter what quota is used. Some analysis states that no-show paradoxes are extremely rare in real-world elections. For one thing, transfers have little effect in general on who is elected, the winners usually being among the front runners in the first round of counting anyway.