obiter dictum

English

Etymology

From Latin obiter dictum (“something said by the way”).

Pronunciation

  • (UK) IPA(key): /ˌəʊbɪtə ˈdɪktəm/
  • (General American) IPA(key): /ˌoʊbɪɾɚ ˈdɪktəm/

Noun

obiter dictum (plural obiter dicta)

Examples

With reference to the example given in the entry of ratio decidendi:

  • Justice Smith delivered the dissenting judgment that "fruits" and "vegetables" should be given their biological meaning, so tomatoes should be classified as a fruit. As this is a minority opinion, this is obiter dictum.
  • Chief Justice Doe, who delivered the majority opinion, states that "based on these reasons, cucumbers and pumpkins should also be classified as vegetables". As this is irrelevant to that case, this statement is obiter dictum. It could become ratio decidendi in other cases if it is cited by a lower court.
  • A lower court of Albion is asked to adjudge a similar case, and the majority opinions from the Eagleland case are submitted for reference. As Albion courts are not bound to follow Eagleland cases, the majority opinions are obiter dictum, unless they are confirmed by a superior court in Albion.
  1. An incidental remark; especially (law) a statement or remark in a court's judgment that is not essential to the disposition of the case. [from 18th c.]
    • 1927, Ernest Bramah [pseudonym; Ernest Brammah Smith], Max Carrados Mysteries:
      All I know is that we had a patent suction jack—for of course we daren't use leverage—capable of raising five tons dead weight drawing on a stone weighing something less than five hundredweight and it couldn't budge it a hair. No, sir; do what we might it had us beaten to cold cinders. And if you want my obiter dictum I should say the biggest thing in W.S. enigmas is waiting patiently there for some bright boy to come along and scoop it.
    • 1971, Keith Thomas, Religion and the Decline of Magic, Folio Society, published 2012, page 128:
      Casual obiter dicta by men of accepted godliness belonged to a different category from the ecstatic claims to immediate revelation made by obscure persons who thrust themselves into the limelight […] .
    • 2010, Jack Tsen-Ta Lee, “The Text through Time”, in Statute Law Review‎[1]:
      However, McHugh J noted obiter dicta that if the meaning of the word was construed at that level of abstraction today, ‘it would deny the Parliament of the Commonwealth the power to legislate for same sex marriages […]’.

Translations