Criticism of the Quran
| Part of a series on |
| Quran |
|---|
|
| This article is of a series on |
| Criticism of religion |
|---|
Criticism of the Quran, the religious text held to be sacred by Islam, often concerns the text's factual accuracy, moral tenability, and supposed inerrancy claimed by ulemas. Muslims regard the Quran as the perfect verbatim word of God revealed to Muhammad.
In critical and historical study, scholars, such as John Wansbrough, Joseph Schacht, Patricia Crone, and Michael Cook, seek to investigate and verify the Quran's origin, text, composition, and history, examining questions, puzzles, difficult text, etc. as they would non-sacred ancient texts. Common criticisms concern the corruption of the oral and textual transmission at the origins, imperfect preservation, reliance on various pre-existing sources, internal inconsistency, lack of clarity, and questionable ethical teachings. The Quran's oral formation and written transmission, before and after Muhammad, have been questioned on the grounds of manuscript variants, the existence of numerous early contradictory narratives of how the Quran was composed, and early sources themselves discussing actual variants among even the followers of Muhammad. Early sources by non-Muslims indicate that there was no Quran at the time of Muhammad since early Christian and Jewish sources on Islam show no awareness of a Muslim scripture during the prophet's lifetime.
Sunni and Shia sects of Islam have competing and contradictory narratives of the origins of the Quran. Scholars argue that the earliest Muslims had a confusing understanding of Muhammad's message and that the emergence of multiple conflicting traditions exhibits many attempts to make sense of the chaos of composition, including examples of dependence on Christian and Jewish texts. No critical text of the Quran, based on manuscript analysis, has ever been made, and this is considered problematic since all other ancient and even sacred literature has been studied for accuracy. Textual critics state that based on the diversity found in the manuscript evidence, the editing after Muhammad's death, early purges of variants, early standardization attempts (e.g., 653–705 AD and 936 AD), along with other factors, lead to the view that there "never was one original text of the Quran."