anti-Sumerist

English

Alternative forms

  • Anti-Sumerist

Etymology

    From anti- + Sumerist.

    Pronunciation

    • Rhymes: -uːməɹɪst

    Noun

    anti-Sumerist (plural anti-Sumerists)

    1. (historical) A member of the 19th-century Assyriological school, chiefly associated with Joseph Halévy, that denied the existence of the Sumerian language (which was still called Akkadian by some late 19th-century scholars), interpreting the apparently non-Semitic features of the cuneiform inscriptions as an allographic or cryptographic system of writing.
      Synonym: (obsolete) anti-Akkadist
      Antonyms: Sumerist, (obsolete) Akkadist
      • 1893, Christopher Johnston, “The Sumero-Akkadian Question”, in Journal of the American Oriental Society, page 319:
        To sum up the whole question in a few words, the Sumerists hold that Sumerian was a real language, spoken by the primitive inhabitants of Babylonia, and appearing in two forms differing from each other either locally or temporally; while the position of J. Halévy and other anti-Sumerists, whose ranks have been strengthened by such distinguished scholars as the late Stanislas Guyard of Paris and Prof. Friedrich Delitzsch of Leipzig, is that it was no language at all, but merely a figment of the priestly class, a pure cryptography.
      • 1893, C. P. Thiele, “On the Study of Comparative Theology”, in John Henry Barrows, editor, The World’ Parliament of Religions: An Illustrated and Popular Story of the World’s First Parliament of Religions, Held in Chicago in Connection with the Columbian Exposition of 1893, volume 1, pages 585–586:
        How much does Brugsch differ in his representation of the Egyptian Mythology from Edward Meyer and Erman; how great a division among the Assyriologists between the Accadists, or Sumerists and the Anti-Sumerists or Anti-Accadists; how much differs the explanation of the Veda by Roth, Müller, Grassman, from that by Ludwig, and how different is Barth’s explanation from Bergaigne’s and Regnaud’s; how violent was the controversy between Spiegel and Haupt about the explanation of the most ancient pieces in the Avesta; and now, in this year of grace, while the younger generation, as Bartholomæ and Geldner on the one hand, Geiger, Wilhelm, Hubschmann, Mills, on the other hand, are following different roads, there has come a scholar and a man of genius, who is, however, particularly fond of paradoxes, James Darmesteter, to overthrow all that was considered up to his time as being all but stable, nay, even to undermine the foundations, which were believed safe enough to be built upon.
      • 1899, The Expository Times, page 71:
        For Halévy it is a point of honour that the Jews should have the credit of inventing the art of writing, and this although a co-religionist has reminded him that such a claim might be waived, seeing that the world owes to the Semites a still greater discovery, that of monotheism. Yet Jeremias thinks that a justifiable aversion to the ‘tendency’ of Halévy’s researches has perhaps made Weissbach somewhat blind to the real merits of the great anti-Sumerist.
      • 1899, Ira M. Price, “Recent Thought on the Origin of the Cuneiform Writing”, in The American Journal of Semitic Languages and Literatures, page 153:
        Early in the third period (1880 to the present) Halévy’s position was adopted by Stanislas Guyard, the first Assyriologist to join hands with the pioneer anti-Sumerist.
      • 1901, J. Dyneley Prince, “The Unilingual Inscriptions K. 138 and K. 3232, translated”, in Journal of the American Oriental Society, page 1:
        Happily for the Assyriological world, the long discussion as to the existence of a non-Semitic “Sumerian” language is rapidly drawing to a close. Indeed, the main question may be considered as practically settled. Even Friedrich Delitzsch, who has been until recently perhaps the most authoritative of the Anti-Sumerists, has at last changed his views and now holds that the Sumerian was really a language and was not merely, as the Anti-Sumerists thought, an ideographic system of writing the Semitic Assyro-Babylonian.

    Translations

    Adjective

    anti-Sumerist

    1. (historical) Of or relating to the anti-Sumerists.
      Synonym: (obsolete) anti-Akkadist
      Antonyms: Sumerist, (obsolete) Akkadist
      • 1991, Aula Orientalis, page 58:
        Both the Sumerist and anti-Sumerist positions had been alaborated primarily on the basis of Sumerian and bilingual texts from seventh century Nineveh.
      • 1993, Revue de l’histoire des religions‎[1], page 170:
        The originator and chief spokesman of this anti-Sumerist movement was Joseph Halévy, [...]

    Translations