What a Catch, Donnie

"What a Catch, Donnie"
Single by Fall Out Boy
from the album Folie à Deux
ReleasedSeptember 7, 2009
RecordedLos Angeles, California
Genre
Length4:50
LabelIsland
Songwriters
ProducerNeal Avron
Fall Out Boy singles chronology
"Headfirst Slide into Cooperstown on a Bad Bet"
(2009)
"What a Catch, Donnie"
(2009)
"Alpha Dog"
(2009)
Music video
"What a Catch, Donnie" on YouTube

"What a Catch, Donnie" is a song recorded by the American rock band Fall Out Boy for their third studio album, Folie à Deux (2008). It was released as the fourth and final single from Folie à Deux in September 2009, through Island Records. "What a Catch, Donnie" was written by bassist Pete Wentz as a tribute to vocalist Patrick Stump, capturing the tension between his recurring self-doubt and musical talent.

The track is a sweeping soul ballad, anchored by piano and lush string arrangements, with its title referencing soul singer Donny Hathaway and including nods to his collaborator Roberta Flack. It evolved into both an introspective reflection and a retrospective on Fall Out Boy's career during a period of uncertainty about the band's future. It contains a key guest appearance from Elvis Costello, one of Stump's longtime heroes. Its bridge features an array of cameos from aughts-era emo hitmakers—including Brendon Urie, Travie McCoy, Gabe Saporta, and more—each reprising a Fall Out Boy song.

Its music video dramatizes Stump adrift at sea, ultimately rescuing his bandmates and collaborators from a sinking ship while surrounded by visual callbacks to the band's past. Critical reception was mixed, with reviewers divided over the song's sentimentality. The song charted near the lower regions of the US and Canadian singles charts.