Werth v. Taylor
| Werth v. Taylor | |
|---|---|
| Court | Michigan Court of Appeals |
| Argued | January 16, 1991 |
| Decided | July 8, 1991 |
| Docket nos. | 123785 |
| Citations | 190 Mich. App. 141 (1991) 475 N.W.2d 426 (Mich. Ct. App. 1991) |
| Court membership | |
| Judges sitting |
|
| Case opinions | |
| Majority | Neff, joined by unanimous |
Werth v. Taylor, 190 Mich. App. 141 (1991), is a case heard by the Michigan Court of Appeals in which the court refused to hold a doctor liable for giving a Jehovah's Witness a life-saving blood transfusion. As a Jehovah's Witness, plaintiff Cindy Werth believed that receiving a blood transfusion would be a sin. After she gave birth, however, she experienced postpartum bleeding. Werth agreed to surgery; she said she did not want blood transfusions, but did not firmly commit to refusing one should it become a life-or-death situation. During the surgery, her condition worsened rapidly; the anesthesiologist, defendant Michael Taylor, gave her a blood transfusion, deeming it necessary to save her life. Werth sued for medical malpractice and battery.
Many states, including Michigan, have held that there is a right to refuse even lifesaving treatment; to intrude on this right is medical battery. However, some states set a high bar on what constitutes a valid refusal for lifesaving treatment; the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania held that a "fully conscious contemporaneous decision by the patient" is required.
The Michigan Court of Appeals ruled for Taylor; the court found that a refusal of lifesaving treatment had to be contemporaneous and informed, similar to Pennsylvania's standard. Because Werth had not refused treatment under the impression that it could be fatal, the court found, it could not be considered contemporaneous or informed. Legal scholars criticized the decision, arguing that the court had made it too difficult for a person to refuse lifesaving treatment in advance of being unconscious.