Two nations theory (Ireland)

In Ireland, the two nations theory proposes that there are two peoples on the island with national rights to self-determination: an Irish nation substantially formed by the Roman Catholic majority; and, concentrated in the north-east (in parts of Ulster), a Protestant community of Scottish and English descent which is insistent on a continued union with Great Britain. Emerging in the 19th century as a response to the drive for Irish self-government, variants of the theory gained renewed currency from the late 1960s when the onset of Northern Ireland Troubles called the 1921 partition settlement into question. Persuaded that there was a prospect of British withdrawal, paramilitary-associated loyalists considered the possibility of Ulster Protestants constituting the core of a national community independent of both London and Dublin. Broader acceptance was found among unionists for a theory reformulated on purportedly Leninist principles by a small left-wing grouping. While blaming the renewed conflict on British misrule, this rejected Ulster nationalism and accepted unionism as a popular expression of a legitimate British interest and identity. Since the 1998 Belfast Agreement, the two-nations perspective has been challenged within unionism by renewed interest in the language and narrative of Ulster Scots, and by the British government's formal recognition of Ulster Scots in 2022 as a "national minority" within the framework of an agreement re-establishing a devolved Northern Ireland Executive.