Swanson v. Roman Catholic Bishop of Portland
| Swanson v. Roman Catholic Bishop of Portland | |
|---|---|
| Court | Maine Supreme Judicial Court |
| Full case name | Albert Swanson, et al. v. Roman Catholic Bishop of Portland, et al. |
| Argued | November 5, 1996 |
| Decided | April 4, 1997 |
| Citation | 692 A.2d 441 |
| Court membership | |
| Chief justice | Daniel Wathen |
| Associate justices | |
| Case opinions | |
| Majority | Wathen, joined by Roberts, Clifford, Rudman |
| Dissent | Lipez, joined by Dana |
Swanson v. Roman Catholic Bishop of Portland, 692 A.2d 441 (Me. 1997), was a decision of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court (Law Court) in which the court held that the First Amendment to the United States Constitution bars negligent supervision claims against a church. Albert and Ruth Swanson alleged that, while undergoing religious marital counselling with Father Maurice Morin of the Diocese of Portland, Morin had an affair with Ruth, leading to a contentious divorce. They sued Morin, the diocese, and the bishop for, among other things, negligent supervision.
The church moved to dismiss the claims against it, arguing that investigating the relationship between the church and its priests would require the court to make decisions of ecclesiastical law, in violation of the Maine Constitution and the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. The Swansons responded that the claim could be resolved based on neutral principles of law, and did not pose any constitutional problems. At the time, Maine courts had not decided whether negligent supervision was even a cause of action under Maine law in the first place.
The Law Court dismissed the claims, agreeing with the church; the majority did not decide whether negligent supervision claims can be sustained under Maine law. However, the court held that even if the cause of action did exist, this particular claim would be barred by the First Amendment. Justice Kermit Lipez wrote for himself and the other dissenting justice that the court had decided the case prematurely, arguing that the case should have proceeded through trial and that the question of whether negligent supervision claims exist should have been decided before reaching a constitutional question. Most legal scholars and courts in other jurisdictions have disagreed with the Law Court's holding in Swanson. The Law Court, after sidestepping the question of negligent supervision in several subsequent cases, eventually held that the cause of action does exist in 2005.