Sheldon tapestries
Sheldon tapestries This classification of tapestries followed the exhibition at the Victoria and Albert Museum, London, in 1914 of the tapestry maps, commissioned by and for the Sheldon family of Beoley and Weston, which had given rise to the question of whether there might be other products from workshops at Barcheston for which there was only a presumption of existence.
One hundred and twenty-one woven tapestries were first identified in the 1920s as products of that weaving venture planned by William Sheldon, outlined in his recently catalogued will, its details previously unknown. Most are small furnishing items, such as cushion covers produced in sets of six depicting a Biblical story. Examples are to be seen in three major collections: the Victoria and Albert Museum, London; the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; and the Burrell Collection, Glasgow, Scotland. The first attributions, then dated to the later 16th century, were made by a Worcestershire antiquary, John Humphreys, without clear criteria but in the belief that William Sheldon’s proposed venture must have been successful. A few years later further examples were so classified on a typological basis, its base point insecure. No documentary evidence was then, or is now, associated with any tapestry, so no definitive origin for any piece can be established. Scholarly criticism, pointing out how much in both articles depended on assumption and association, was immediate but went un-noticed and is still ignored. Recent research, based largely on stylistic traits seen in tapestries from documented, usually continental, workshops or by identifying design elements taken from prints has both re-dated and re-attributed many of the early ascriptions.
Only three large sets, each with a local first owner, were so-called; five tapestries once at Chastleton House, Oxfordshire, the Four Seasons now at Hatfield House, and the four tapestry maps depicting the counties of Gloucestershire, Warwickshire, Worcestershire and Oxfordshire. Again, recent research against a wider range of Elizabethan sources than employed in the 1920s and, during conservation, close study of the quality of weaving raises doubts about the claims of any of the large tapestries to be Barcheston work.