Revisionist school of Islamic studies

The revisionist school of Islamic studies (also critical school of Islamic studies and critical historians of Islam) is a scientific movement in Islamic studies that questions traditional Muslim narratives of the origins of the religion of Islam.

In the early 1970s some non-Muslim Islamic scholars (called "revisionists" later) began to question the traditional / conventional accounts of the rise of Islam. This origin story and the reliability of its traditional "literary sources" was subscribed to not only by the Islamic world but in large part by most non-Muslim Islamic scholars. Revisionists had doubts about these traditional sources—which included accounts of what the Islamic prophet Muhammad and his followers said, did, approved of, etc, passed down orally and then written down 150 to 250 years afterwards—that (the new scholars argued) were subject to biases of and embellishments by the authors and transmitters. To these traditional sources revisionists proposed employing a "source-critical" approach, including relevant archaeology, epigraphy, numismatics, and contemporary non-Arabic literature that they argued provided "hard facts" and an ability to crosscheck.

Revisionist scholars include John Wansbrough and his students Andrew Rippin, Norman Calder, G. R. Hawting, Patricia Crone and Michael Cook; as well as Fred Donner, Günter Lüling, Yehuda D. Nevo and Christoph Luxenberg; Tom Holland, and Ibn Warraq; who all drew on the earlier work of Ignác Goldziher and Joseph Schacht.

Their theories are "by no means" monolithic, but they do share some "methodological premises", and theories: namely that the basic principles of what we know of as Islam was formed not just during the ten years of Muhammad's mission (622–632 CE), but over a considerably longer period including the 7th-century Arab invasion of Byzantine and Persian empires, Rashidun caliphs and the Umayyad Caliphs; that the religious, political, cultural break between the civilizations of Persia and Byzantium, and the new 7th-century Arab Muslim empire, was not as abrupt as the traditional history describes; that Muhammad did not come from the city of Mecca and the belief that he did is an invented tradition from decades after his death; that the relationship between Muhammad and Jews and Christians may have originally been much less hostile than traditionally described. Issues not agreed on include the historicity of Muhammad and questions about the Quran, such as when it first appeared, how it was written, and how it was transmitted from one generation to another in its early years.