Metabasis paradox
The metabasis paradox is an instance in Aristotle's Poetics where, according to many scholars, he makes two incompatible statements. In chapter 13 of the book, Aristotle states that for tragedy to end in misfortune is "correct," yet in chapter 14 he judges a type of plot in tragedy "best" that does not end in misfortune. Since the 16th century, scholars in Classics have puzzled over this contradiction or have proposed solutions, of which there are at least three from the 21st century alone. Gotthold Lessing's solution has been the most influential yet there is not a consensus.
In chapter 13, Aristotle argues that tragedy should consist of a change of fortune from good to bad. Subsequently, he writes also in chapter 13 that, while critics have judged Euripides harshly because "many" of his plays "end in misfortune," yet "this is, as we have seen, correct," referring to the change of fortune from good to bad. Then, in chapter 14, he identifies the incident that creates fear and pity, killing "among family," in which the killer could either kill or not, and either knowingly or unknowingly. Aristotle finds that in the "best" version, the killer recognizes the victim and does not kill. Since that narrative does not end in misfortune, scholars often conclude that chapter 14 seems to contradict 13.
In 2016, Arata Takeda published a chapter-length study of the problem from the Renaissance up to the late 20th century, omitting 21st century work. Takeda's 2016 chapter deviated from the standard description of the solutions of André Dacier, Gotthold Lessing, and Stephen Halliwell. In 2025, however, Takeda published in German a comprehensive history of the problem from the Renaissance to the 21st century, following up on his earlier work.
In Takeda's 2016 publication he proposed a name for the problem, "metabasis paradox," from metabasis, "change," Aristotle's term in the Poetics for change of fortune. The creator of this Wikipedia article borrowed the name from Takeda. The phrase has never yet been adopted by professional classical scholars for the contradiction of chapters 13 and 14. For a brief time in the early 2020s as this article was noticed online, the name was misappropriated for other paradoxes concerning tragic guilt in the Poetics. Those misuses have faded from view as of 2026. In his 2025 book, Takeda suggested instead the clearer term, GlĂĽckswechselparadox (change of fortune paradox).