Mansabdar

The court of Akbar, from the Akbarnama. A mansab fixed its holder's precedence at gatherings such as this, together with his pay and the cavalry he owed the state.

The mansabdari system was the framework of graded ranks through which the Mughal Empire appointed, paid and obliged its officers. Every civil and military servant of the empire above the lowest levels held a mansab, a numerical rank that fixed his precedence, determined his salary, and bound him to maintain a stated number of cavalry with horses and equipment. A mansab conferred no office in itself, and its holder could be posted to almost any branch of the administration. Because the empire's civil officers were drawn from the holders of these military ranks, the arrangement fused the army, the nobility and the civil service into a single hierarchy, and it covered every public service except the judiciary.

The ranks were decimal, an inheritance from Mongol and Timurid practice, and branding and descriptive rolls had precedents under the Delhi Sultanate and Sher Shah. The system in its developed form is associated with Akbar, although historians disagree whether it should be dated to a single moment in the 1570s or treated as accreting across the second half of his reign. From about 1595 a mansab was stated as two numbers: the zat, which governed personal pay and standing, and the sawar, which governed the contingent to be maintained. What the pair meant has been contested since the nineteenth century, with Blochmann, Irvine, R. P. Tripathi and Abdul Aziz all proposing different readings; Aziz's account is now the standard one, though M. Athar Ali held that the zat figure became largely fictitious from the close of Akbar's reign.

Mansabdars were paid either in cash or, more often, by jagir, an assignment of land revenue that carried no rights of ownership or residence and was normally transferred every few years. Because assessed valuations regularly exceeded actual collections, salaries and military obligations alike came to be scaled by a system of "month" ratios, and from Shah Jahan's reign contingents were formally set at a third, a quarter or a fifth of nominal rank. The salary bill was enormous, absorbing on one reconstruction some 80 per cent of the empire's assessed revenue. Verification rested on branding horses and keeping descriptive rolls of men, administered by the mir bakhshi, whose certification was required before pay was released; even so, contemporaries and modern historians agree that contingents habitually fell short of their paper strength.

The system was also the instrument by which the Mughals recruited a deliberately mixed elite of Turanis, Iranis, Afghans, Indian Muslims, Rajputs and, under Aurangzeb, Deccanis and Marathas. Its later history is dominated by the jagirdari crisis, the growing mismatch between the number of rank-holders and the pool of assignable revenue, whose causes and significance remain disputed among Satish Chandra, Athar Ali, Irfan Habib and their critics. After 1707 the ranks decayed into hereditary and largely honorific holdings, and elements of the form survived in the successor states. Comparison with the Ottoman timar has been common since Bernier, though historians differ over how far it holds. Scholarship on the subject moved from the philological work of Blochmann and Irvine, through Moreland, Aziz and Ibn Hasan, to the statistical turn of the Aligarh historians, and more recently to revisionists who question the picture of a tightly centralised bureaucracy.