M v R

M. v R
CourtHigh Court of Australia
Full case name M v The Queen
Decided13 December 1994
Citations[1994] HCA 63, 181 CLR 487
Court membership
Judges sittingMason CJ, Brennan, Deane, Dawson, Toohey, Gaudron & McHugh JJ
Case opinions
(4:3)

appeal allowed
even making full allowance for the manner in which (the accused and complainant) gave their evidence, the matters which cast doubt upon the prosecution case ... remain unanswered
(per Mason CJ, Deane, Dawson, and Toohey JJ)
partial concurrence
appeal on intercourse counts ought be allowed, while the sexual assault counts ought be retried
(per Gaudron J)

dissenting
no facts are present in this case that merit a court's assessment prevailing over the jury
(per Brennan J)
the correct test should be whether a reasonable jury must have had a reasonable doubt, this was not the case
(per McHugh J)

M v R or M v The Queen is an Australian legal case decided in the High Court. It is an important authority in the field of criminal law, for the circumstances in which it is permissible for a jury's guilty verdict to be overturned by a judge. The case involved an appeal against criminal conviction by a father, against allegations of sexual assault and rape by his daughter. His appeal was allowed by majority.