In re Neely

In re Neely
CourtWyoming Supreme Court
DecidedMarch 7, 2017 (2017-03-07)
Citation390 P.3d 728
Case history
Subsequent actionscertiorari denied, 583 U.S. 1052
Court membership
Chief judgeE. James Burke
Associate judges
Case opinions
MajorityFox, joined by Burke, Hill
DissentKautz, joined by Davis
Laws applied

In re Neely, 390 P.3d 728 (Wyo. 2017), is a Wyoming Supreme Court case in which the court censured Ruth Neely, a local judge who publicly said that she would not perform same-sex marriages. Neely was appointed to a part-time magistrate judgeship in 2001. Following the United States Supreme Court's nationwide legalization of same-sex marriage, Neely told the press and a superior that, for religious reasons, she would not be willing to perform a same-sex marriage. Her superior suspended her and the Wyoming Commission of Judicial Conduct and Ethics found there was probable cause to believe Neely violated several parts of the Wyoming Code of Judicial Conduct. The commission recommended that Neely be expelled; Neely appealed the ruling to the Wyoming Supreme Court.

In a 3–2 decision, the Wyoming Supreme Court found that Neely had committed ethics violations, holding that her comments breached her duties to avoid impropriety and the appearance of it, to impartially and fairly uphold and execute the laws, and to perform her duties without bias or prejudice. However, the court chose to censure her rather than expel her. The dissent disagreed, arguing that the majority had penalized Neely for expression of her religious beliefs, highlighting that Neely had not been asked to perform a same-sex marriage and that her position only authorized her to perform marriages rather than mandating it. Several legal scholars criticized the decision, seeing it as an infringement on Neely's religious freedoms.