Grammar of Assent

Head shot of John Henry Newman
John Henry Newman, the author

An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent (commonly abbreviated Grammar of Assent) is Saint John Henry Newman's seminal book on the philosophy of faith. Completed in 1870, the book took Newman 20 years to write, he confided to friends. It was dedicated to his friend and fellow convert, the lawyer Edward Bellasis.

Newman's aim was to show that the scientific standards for evidence and assent are too narrow and inapplicable in concrete life. He argued that logic and its conclusions are not transferable to real life decision making as such. As a result, it is inappropriate to judge the validity of assent in concrete faith by conventional logical standards because paper logic is unequal to the task. "Logic is loose at both ends," he said, meaning that the process of logic initially depends on restrictive assumptions and is thus unable to fit its conclusions neatly into real world situations.

Instead, Newman argued our beliefs come from what he called "the illative sense", that which weighs evidence from all kinds of inputs, logical, instinctive, and authoritative, among others, to reach or fall short of assent. “It is the mind that reasons, and that controls its own reasonings, not any technical apparatus of words and propositions. This power of judging and concluding, when in its perfection, I call the Illative Sense.”