Gender-equality paradox
| Part of a series on |
| Sex differences in humans |
|---|
| Biology |
| Medicine and health |
| Neuroscience and psychology |
| Sociology and society |
| Related |
The gender-equality paradox is the counterintuitive finding that various average gender differences in personality and occupational choices are larger in countries that score higher in standard gender equality metrics. Larger differences are found in Big Five personality traits, Dark Triad traits, self-esteem, depression, personal values, occupational and educational choices. These finding are mostly derived from the statistical comparison between standard international measures of gender equality and standard psychological and economic data of gender differences. The most used standard equality indicators such as the Gender Parity Index scores a country higher in equality according to the existence and size of a standard set of female achievement disadvantages such as in leadership or education, with critiques arguing these instruments are flawed due to the absence of measures of real-world gendered treatment, broader women's disadvantages, national specificities, gender stereotypes as well as disadvantages affecting men and other gender groups.
Various explanations for the paradox have been proposed, for example that women in less developed nations are more likely to choose STEM fields based on the increased need for security and good pay. Some scholars instead suggest that gender stereotypes in more gender equal countries are responsible. Some psychologists have asserted that this account merely pushes the question one step back: why do essentialist stereotypes regarding aptitudes (e.g., math ability or interests) appear stronger or more behaviorally influential precisely in societies with the highest gender equality and economic development, rather than weakening as traditional barriers diminish? Some have further argued that the persistence or amplification of such stereotypes may itself reflect deeper innate differences in average interests and preferences that become more freely expressed in low-constraint environments.
The most prominent use of the term is in relation to the disputed claim that increased gender differences in participation in STEM careers arise in countries that have more gender equality, based on a study in Psychological Science by Gijsbert Stoet and David C. Geary, which received substantial coverage in non-academic media outlets. However, separate Harvard researchers were unable to recreate the data reported in the study, and in December 2019, a correction was issued to the original paper. The correction outlined that the authors had created a previously undisclosed and unvalidated method to measure "propensity" of women and men to attain a higher degree in STEM, as opposed to the originally claimed measurement of "women's share of STEM degrees". However, even incorporating the newly disclosed method, the investigating researchers could not recreate all the results presented. A follow-up paper in Psychological Science by the researchers who discovered the discrepancy found conceptual and empirical problems with the gender-equality paradox in STEM hypothesis. Another 2020 study did find evidence of the paradox in the pursuit of mathematical studies; however, they found that "the stereotype associating math to men is stronger in more egalitarian and developed countries" and could "entirely explain the gender-equality paradox". Nonetheless, two reports from the United Nations detected the gender-equality paradox in their studies on women and STEM.