Ex parte Rodriguez

Ex parte Rodriguez
CourtSupreme Court of Texas
DecidedJanuary 6, 1874
Citation39 Tex. 705 (1874)
Court membership
Judges sittingWesley Ogden, Moses B. Walker, John David McAdoo
Case opinions
Decision byWalker

Ex parte Rodriguez, 39 Tex. 705 (1874), also known as the Semicolon Case, was a decision of the Supreme Court of Texas. Had it been enforced, the Court's decision would have legally invalidated the 1873 Texas gubernatorial election as unconstitutional, based in part on its interpretation of a semicolon in the Constitution of Texas. The 1869 Texas Constitution provided that local, county, and state elections were to be held in the relevant county seat for four days, but also allowed the Legislature to create a new election law. Prior to the 1873 election, the Legislature provided for one election day to be held in local precincts. Richard Coke, a Democrat, won the 1873 gubernatorial election against the incumbent Governor of Texas, Edmund J. Davis, a Radical Republican. Shortly after the election, the Harris County Sheriff arrested a Mexican man named Joseph Rodriguez, allegedly for voting twice in the election. Rodriguez's attorneys, both prominent Republicans, challenged his arrest by a writ of habeas corpus in the Texas Supreme Court. The State, represented by the Harris and Travis County District Attorneys with support from several prominent Democratic members of the Texas bar and former judges, contended that Rodriguez had not violated the law and that his attorneys were colluding with allies of the outgoing Texas Governor Davis to void the election. The Court heard the case, and, relying in part on the placement of a semicolon in the Constitution, held that the election law was unconstitutional, effectively voiding the election. Coke and his allies ignored the decision, seizing power from Davis. Legal commentators have split on the soundness of the Court's legal reasoning.