Deliberative indispensability argument
The deliberative indispensability argument is an argument for normative realism defended by David Enoch, most prominently in his 2011 book Taking Morality Seriously. The argument states that there are objective normative truths about what people should do or think. Enoch was inspired by other indispensability arguments in the philosophy of mathematics. These arguments justify belief in mathematical objects like numbers because they are indispensable for scientific explanation. Enoch applied a similar idea to justify belief in normative truths, arguing that they are indispensable to deliberation.
The argument claims that deliberation is rationally non-optional because deliberating is required to act in the world. It further claims that the only way to make sense of deliberation is with normative truths. This is because deliberation seems to be a search for objectively right answers about the correct decision to make in a given situation. The argument concludes that it is justified to believe in normative truths. Counterarguments include the idea that deliberation does not require objectively right answers because it could be based on subjective desires, and that deliberation is not adequately connected to the truth to justify beliefs.