Court of disputed returns
A court of disputed returns is a court, tribunal, or some other body that determines disputes about elections in some common law countries. The court may be known by another name such as 'court of disputed elections'.
In countries that derive their legal tradition from the United Kingdom, the legal tradition is that Parliament is the supreme law-making body in the country. The same tradition mandates that as Parliament is sovereign, it alone has authority and jurisdiction to determine who and how a person can be elected to Parliament. Implicit in that authority is the jurisdiction to determine whether a person has been validly elected, which is commonly known as a "disputed return" and gives the court its name. The court is an attempt to eliminate the partisan nature of parliament and give the determination of electoral disputes to an independent and dispassionate neutral body. As parliament has the sole authority to determine these matters, parliament must create a special law to bring that body into existence to determine those disputes.
A court of disputed returns may be constituted in a number of ways. The first is by the creation of a special court to perform that function. That has occurred in the Northern Territory, Australia, which has a special and separate court determines those disputes.
Another method is for an existing court to be given the role of adjudicating election disputes. The High Court of Australia, the Supreme Court of New South Wales and the Supreme Court of Victoria are each invested as courts of disputed returns in this manner; when handling relevant cases, they sit under the name Court of Disputed Returns. A court may also have the power to handle election disputes without being designated as the Court of Disputed Returns as such, though performing much the same function.
In some jurisdictions, the principle of Parliamentary sovereignty means that the legislature itself retains the ultimate authority to handle election disputes; notwithstanding the fact that this authority may be delegated to the Court, Parliament holds the right to overrule it.
Generally courts of disputed return have no rights of appeal, but that depends on the law that constitutes the court.