Anti-greenhouse effect

The anti-greenhouse effect is a natural phenomenon that occurs when radiant energy from a star (sun) is absorbed or scattered by the upper atmosphere of an orbiting (typically planetary-mass) celestial object, preventing that solar energy from reaching the latter's surface and resulting in a negative net heat transfer (i.e. cooling) to the surface – the opposite of a greenhouse effect. In an ideal case where the upper atmosphere absorbs all solar irradiance (heat gain) and is nearly transparent to infrared dissipation (heat loss) from the surface, the equilibrium temperature of the lower atmosphere (troposphere and stratosphere) would be reduced by 16%, which is a significant amount of surface cooling.

This anti-greenhouse effect has been discovered on Saturn's moon Titan. In Titan's stratosphere, a haze composed of organic tholin aerosols simultaneously absorbs sunlight and is nearly transparent to infrared dissipation from Titan's surface. The dynamic competition between surface warming from sunlight and surface cooling from infrared heat escape is marked by a thermodynamic equilibrium where the greenhouse effect warms Titan by 21 K while the anti-greenhouse effect cools Titan by 9 K, so the net warming is 12 K (= 21 K - 9 K).

It has been suggested that Earth potentially had a similar photochemical haze during the Archean eon, causing an anti-greenhouse effect that was counterbalanced by strong greenhouse effect from then-abundant atmospheric methane, and it is theorized that this haze helped to regulate and stabilize Earth's early climate on the backdrop of an evolving faint young Sun. This equilibrium was permanently disrupted at the end of the Archean by the Great Oxygenation Event, which removed most of the atmospheric methane and subsequently led to a 300-megaannum-long icehouse period known as the Huronian glaciation during the early Proterozoic eon, until global surface temperature finally re-stabilized to temperate levels during the Boring Billion. This equilibrium was disrupted again during the Cryogenian when a combination of reduced greenhouse effect due to the Neoproterozoic Oxygenation Event (which significantly reduced atmospheric carbon dioxide) and enhanced anti-greenhouse effect from volcanic sulfur aerosols led to another global ice age known as the Snowball Earth.

Other atmospheric phenomena besides tholin hazes can also act similarly to the anti-greenhouse effect, such as Earth's stratospheric ozone layer and thermosphere, ejecta particulates (especially sulfur dioxide and sulfates) from volcanic eruption plumes and impact events (which can cause volcanic winter and impact winter, respectively), nuclear fallouts (which can cause nuclear winter), and dust in Mars's upper atmosphere. Outside of the Solar System, calculations of the impact of these hazes on the thermal structure of exoplanets have also been conducted.